De omnibus dubitandum
5 Jun 2008
A recent Boston Globe article sheds some interesting light on the question of extraterrestrial life. Regardless of some flawed assumptions the author makes in the course of coming to his point, he poses a theory worth contemplating. Are we as a self-aware, sentient lifeforms an exception in the universe, or a commonplace occurrence? If life is ubiquitous, why haven’t we heard from any other advanced civilization yet? The article’s author explains this with what he calls the Great Filter – an obstacle or inevitable event that prevents the evolution of life to complete the path to advanced space-faring civilization.
Personally I think there is other intelligent life out there, and the sole reason we haven’t heard from them yet is that we’ve been listening the wrong way. Radio may seem like a logical way to propagate signals, but already we have begun radiating less and less radio signals into space as we’re switching to a digital communications network. If there are advanced extraterrestrials out there, my guess is they’re waiting for us to reach a certain threshold of technological development, one that allows us to communicate with them with compatible technologies.
Or there is a Great Filter and we’re likely doomed to go extinct. Oops.
3 Responses for "Life on Mars is bad news for humanity?"
Nah, it’s just because humans are made of meat. Ick.
Well, maybe something is place like first Contact rules?
Don’t contact them until such or such is reached with a civilization before we contact them.
In our case, maybe we need to become peaceful. Not going to happen anytime soon…
Richard
Depends. Humans will become nominally peaceful with each other quite readily, so long as they have something else they can collectively gang up on. Comes from that half-baked cross between a herd-mind and a pack-mind that effortlessly manages to be vastly less than the sum of its contributing parts. If the aliens came to visit, the human race would be using the aliens’ own technology to terraform their planets, colonize them, and serve up alienburgers with extra catsup within a decade, tops. And at each others’ throats again in another.
Of course, one way or another, you’re going to have to figure out a way to get around that lightspeed limitation before any of this moves out of the realm of science fiction of various levels of silliness (or philosophy, which is even sillier). You don’t need a filter, just a reasonable grasp of how much effort it’s really worth to try to talk to someone who lives more than a handful of light-years away. To paraphrase Douglas Adams, space is an awfully big place.
Leave a reply