De omnibus dubitandum
16 Feb 2009
A new study among US soldiers in a mock interrogation exercise proves once again that human memories are ridiculously easy to manipulate:
The study of misinformation and false memories have consistently shown that human beings are highly susceptible to suggestion. Much of the work has focused on creating or changing people’s memories of the past.
Apparently creating false memories is very easy and likely very common in daily life. This has some uncomfortable consequences:
The research calls into question the entire eyewitness-based legal system. False memories implanted by researchers, it turns out, look basically identical to real memories. Neuroimaging machines can’t tell them apart and neither can researchers.
However counter-intuitive it might be, we have to accept that what we remember and what actually happened are probably different things. And we really need to get rid of eyewitnesses in court cases.
4 Responses for "False Memories"
My mother is a master at remembering things her own special way. It’s rather frustrating.
I like you last phrase. It is a logical conclusion from the info you provided and really made me think. Eye witnesses are the core of the criminal justice system right now. Their testimony, if it makes sense, is worth more than a lot of the other tools especially in jury cases. I’m not sure that removing eye witnesses altogether would be that good an idea. Our memories are not consistently completely different from reality… then again, maybe i’m remembering wrong
. I simply think that less biased methods should really be taking the front seat. I think that this is the way the justice system is going.
i live in australia, at the age of 15, i was shot in the head, i had neurosurgery the day after my 16th birthday. I have mental health issues for quite a few years now. I also have false memories from when i was a child. these memories have not been ‘implanted’ but are things that i have come up w/ on my own. my mother tells me that they are not true. i have looked for help on Aussie websites but there seems to be none, please get bak to me if you feel you can help, Niki
[...] don’t even need to be based on actual events. They can be created without the person ever experiencing anything even remotely close to it. A story you heard, a dream [...]
Leave a reply